The CSF protests “Who’s There?” movie advertisement
The CSF Protest to Police Commissioner and Censor Board to halt film
Complaint also filed with Vakola Police Station, Mumbai for registering offence
The Catholic-Christian Secular Forum (CSF), the Mumbai-based activist community NGO takes strong exception to the movie Who’s There? (Kaun Hai Waha?) which hurts Christian sentiments for its portrayal of the community. The CSF general secretary, Joseph Dias, has in a complaint protested against an advertisement showing Jesus Christ on the Cross and a man moving menacing, knife in hand, towards him to stab him. The advertisement is featured in the media as pre-release publicity poster with the a caption – “This time evil will win” which mocks the Christian faith.
The CSF will stall the release scheduled for 18th November, unless it is satisfied that the Church and the religion are shown in proper light. The movie is directed by Ejaz Ahmed and produced by Wasim Shaikh, which has hurt religious feelings and hence is a punishable offence. The makers of the movie know nothing about Church exorcism, since the film deals with a ghost haunting a newly married couple.
Joseph Dias points out that even the category of certification ( Universal or Adults ) is not mentioned in the advertisement and hence, as per Rule 38 of Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983, non compliance of this rule is a cognizable and non-bailable offence under section 7 of Cinematograph Act 1952.
According to The CSF, the Christian faith is misinterpreted and shown in bad light. The move will disturb communal harmony and action can also be taken under sections 153A , 153B & 505 (1 & 2) of the Indian Penal Code, section 295 of the Criminal Procedure Code and other relevant laws of the land. ” Is it possible that a man be shown attacking Allah or any other god in a film or poster? Then why should a man be shown in such a manner with the Christian God? asks Joseph Dias.
The CSF will also campaign for a Blasphemy Law, covering “no offence to any religion”, with leaders of other faiths and present a memorandum to the federal law & minorities minister, Salman Khurshid, as in India religion is a very sensitive issue with all faiths.
Joseph Dias also points out that the 5B (2)guidelines of the Censor Board are also reasons to act, which states – The film is to be examined in the interests of public order, decency or involves defamation or contempt of court. The courts have repeatedly urged sensitivity and that the contemporary standards, be kept in mind, besides the opinions of the people, whom the film portrays. Some CBFC guidelines that the film violates and reasons for not granting it a screening certificate are under the following:
1. I) the film must be responsible and sensitive to the values and standards of society;
2. iv) pointless or avoidable scenes of violence, cruelty & horror, de-sensitising or de-humanising people.
2. v ) scenes which have the effect of justifying or glorifying drinking are not shown
2. xii) visuals or words contemptuous of racial, religious or other groups are not presented.
2. xiii) visuals or words which promote communal, obscurantist, anti-scientific… are not presented.
2. xviii) visuals or words involving defamation or contempt of court are not presented….
In view of the above, The CSF calls for the movie certificate to be recalled, if given and action taken against those who have made it, to serve as a deterrent. Joseph Dias has complained to the authorities to register an offence and said, if need be, The CSF will go to court and seek remedial action.
CAIRO, Egypt, May 9 (CDN) — At least 12 people were killed and more than 200 were wounded when members of a conservative Muslim movement attacked two churches and surrounding Christian-owned homes and businesses in a poor section of Cairo on Saturday (May 7).
Salifis, a hard-line Islamic movement with extremist tendencies, set fire to one of the two church buildings, leaving most of it gutted. The arson attack on the Virgin Mary Church in Imbaba was one of many recent assaults on Coptic Christians by members of the Salafist movement, and the second time in two months that a church building in the country has been set ablaze.
The Rev. Mittias Ilias, head priest of the Virgin Mary Church in Imbaba, said the attack was senseless and beyond trying to explain with words.
“We don’t talk – the church screams for itself,” he said. “The church has five floors, and there is no space where the fire didn’t reach. The floors, the ceiling, the pillars, the church box, the chairs, the icons, all of it – everything was burned. Just give me one reason for all that. There is no reason for all that, nothing.”
The first attack started early Saturday evening (May 7) at St. Mina Church in Imbaba, one of the poorest districts of Cairo. A rumor spread that a Coptic woman who allegedly converted to Islam was being held in the church against her will. No one contacted by Compass in Imbaba could say definitively how the rumor got started, but by 7:30 p.m., according to one victim of the attack, crowds of Muslims chanting Islamic slogans and shouting Osama bin Laden’s name began marching down the streets.
Coptic community members began calling each other about a potential attack, and many started to gather at the church building. The Coptic men dragged pews and other furniture out of the building and built barricades on the streets that access it.
In attempts to dispel the rumor, the head clergy members of St. Mina allowed a group of Islamic imams into the church building to search for the woman. The imams declared to the gathering Muslims that the woman wasn’t in the building, according to witnesses at the scene.
Reports of who struck the first blows were contradictory, but the Salafist crowd was not dissuaded by the imams’ report, and by 8:30 p.m. the fight had started.
Christian witnesses of the attack said the Salafis, carrying knives and other weapons, attacked the men on the barricades, eventually hurling Molotov cocktails at them. There were numerous reports that the Salafis were armed with military-style assault weapons.
Muslim community members and at least one Egyptian Army officer said the Copts had weapons, a charge that all Copts interviewed vehemently denied.
Ramses Roushdy, 43, was injured in the attack. He said a piece of glass went into his eye from an exploding Molotov cocktail while he was defending his father, a lay leader in the church.
“It wasn’t like a rock or a stone hit me,” he said. “It was like there was an explosion, and a bunch of fragments hit me all over my body.”
The mob also attacked Coptic-owned business in Imbaba and apartments adjacent to the church. Roushdy’s cousin, Nashaat Ratieb, who lived close to the church, was killed in those attacks. According to local media reports, another man whose apartment was raided jumped to his death rather than face his attackers.
After unsuccessfully trying to push through the barricades, the mob went to the Virgin Mary Church, an undefended building a 10-minute walk from St. Mina. According to Ilias, the mob shot through locks on the church doors, went in and set the building on fire.
A few men were in the building when it was attacked. All escaped except for one, Salah Aziz, the church attendant. A group of youths trying to extinguish embers from the fire discovered his body in a side room of the sanctuary that was used a baptismal, Ilias said.
“We are believers. We believe that whoever dies goes to heaven to be with Christ,” Ilias said. “But myself and all of us personally, we get upset and feel bad for his family, his wife and children.”
The fire gutted the five-story structure except for a small chapel on the top floor of the building, which sustained substantial smoke damage. A few items scattered throughout the church building – mostly charred pews and one icon – were unscathed.
Ilias said he didn’t know how long it would take to reconstruct the building. The congregation will continue worshipping in the gutted building and hold services in shifts between renovation stints; they have no choice.
“Where are we going to go?” Ilias said. “Where are the people going to pray?”
The army and security forces did not arrive on the scene until two hours after the attacks had almost fizzled out, according to witnesses.
Fire crews were deployed to the scene but did not get the fire under control for four hours. By Sunday (May 8), officials had cordoned off the area around both church buildings, established a curfew and blocked all media access the scene of the St. Mina attack.
The army allowed partial access to the Virgin Mary Church. Local media reported today that the army has pledged to rebuild the damaged building.
Demonstrations about the attacks continued to surge through areas of Cairo today, with reports of several demonstrators being arrested or injured.
Saturday’s attacks were most serious of a string of attacks and threats made by Salafis against Coptic Christians since the fall of the Hosni Mubarak regime earlier this year. Since the government collapse, members of the movement have ratcheted up their attacks and their rhetoric against the Copts, going as far as to cut off the ear of a Coptic man in Qena they accused of renting an apartment to prostitutes.
The movement, some Copts said, is trying to incite violence between the Muslim majority and the Coptic minority, now estimated to be 7 to 10 percent of Egypt’s population of 83 million. On Friday (May 6), several thousand Copts gathered at St. Mark’s Cathedral in Cairo in response to threats made by Salafis, who pattern their belief and practices on the first three generations of Muslims.
The Salafis demanded the church hand over a woman they say converted to Islam from Christianity; they claim the church is hiding her. There is no proof the woman ever converted. She has appeared publicly twice, once in a recorded statement in October and once on live TV on Saturday stating she wasn’t a Muslim and had never converted.
The Salafis had declared they were going to protest outside the church building after making a week of threats against Christians, including a threat to kill the head of the Coptic Orthodox Church, Pope Shenouda III. The leaders of the Salafi protest later canceled the demonstration so they could protest the killing of Bin Laden at the U.S. Embassy in Cairo. Fady Phillip, 25, a member of the church at the counter-protest, said he thought the Salafis were trying to provoke a civil war in Egypt along religious lines.
“They are going to deny they are provoking a civil war,” he said. “They can claim that as much as they want, but who can understand that they would break into my church in order to take the pope as a hostage and ask all the Christians to be silent?”